Composition Forum 18, Summer http: The Moves that Matter in Academic Writing. Jason Arthur and Anne Case-Halferty In Beyond the Culture Wars and, a decade later, in Clueless in AcademeGerald Graff offered arguments that spurred much debate about the content, nature, and efficacy of academic intervention into the arguments of public life.
Posted on March 3, by Scott Alexander I have heard the following from a bunch of people, one of whom was me six months ago: They seem to be saying things that are either morally repugnant or utterly ridiculous. And just as well try to give a quick summary of the sweeping elegaic paeans to a bygone age of high culture and noble virtues that is Reaction.
But there is some content, and some of it is disconcerting. I started reading a little about Reaction after incessantly being sent links to various Mencius Moldbug posts, and then started hanging out in an IRC channel with a few Reactionaries including the infamous Konkvistador whom I could question about it.
Obviously this makes me the world expert who is completely qualified to embark on the hitherto unattempted project of explaining it to everyone else. Trying to sum up their ideas seems like a good way to first of all get a reference point for what their ideas are, and second of all to make it clearer why I think they deserve a rebuttal.
I have tried to be charitable towards these ideas, which means this post will be pushing politically incorrect and offensive positions. If you do not want to read it, especially the middle parts which are about race, I would totally understand that.
But if you do read it and accuse me of holding these ideas myself and get really angry, then you fail at reading comprehension forever.
I originally planned to follow this up tomorrow with the post containing my arguments against these positions, but this argument took longer than I thought to write and I expect the counterargument will as well. Expect a post critiquing reactionary ideas sometime in the next…week?
This is the post where I argue that modern society is rotten to the core, and that the only reasonable solution is to dig up King James II, clone him, and give the clone absolute control over everything.
The imperial Chinese thought nothing could beat imperial China, the medieval Spaniards thought medieval Spain was a singularly impressive example of perfection, and Communist Soviets were pretty big on Soviet Communism.
Meanwhile, we think 21st-century Western civilization, with its democracy, secularism, and ethnic tolerance is pretty neat. Since the first three examples now seem laughably wrong, we should be suspicious of the hypothesis that we finally live in the one era whose claim to have gotten political philosophy right is totally justified.
Speak out against the Chinese Empire and you lose your head. Speak out against the King of Spain and you face the Inquisition.
Speak out against Comrade Stalin and you get sent to Siberia. The great thing about western liberal democracy is that it has a free marketplace of ideas. Everybody criticizes some aspect of our society. Noam Chomsky made a career of criticizing our society and became rich and famous and got a cushy professorship.
I say we need two Stalins! You have found a way to criticize the government in Stalinist Russia and totally get away with it. Who knows, you might even get that cushy professorship. Western society has been moving gradually further to the left for the past several hundred years at least.
It went from divine right of kings to constutitional monarchy to libertarian democracy to federal democracy to New Deal democracy through the civil rights movement to social democracy to???. No, fifty times faster! If you start suggesting maybe it should switch directions and move the direction opposite the one the engine is pointed, then you might have a bad time.
Go back to sterilizing the disabled and feeble-minded. If you really need convincing, suggest re-implementing segregation, or how about slavery? See how far freedom of speech gets you. In America, it will get you fired from your job and ostracized by nearly everyone.
Depending on how loudly you do it, people may picket your house, or throw things at you, or commit violence against you which is then excused by the judiciary because obviously they were provoked.
Despite the iconic image of the dissident sent to Siberia, this is how the Soviets dealt with most of their iconoclasts too. And Western society just happens to have a really strong progressivist immune system ready to gobble you up if you say anything insufficiently progressive.
We medieval Spaniards are way too smart to fall for the balance fallacy! Since you are a citizen of a repressive society, you should be extremely skeptical of all the information you get from schools, the media, and popular books on any topic related to the areas where active repression is occurring.To this end, Graff and Birkenstein have recently published a textbook “companion” to Clueless titled They Say / I Say: The Moves that Matter in Academic Writing ().
The textbook’s stated aim is to “democratiz[e] academic culture.”. The best-selling book on academic writing-in use at more than 1, schools.
They Say / I Say identifies the key rhetorical moves in academic writing, showing students how to frame their arguments in the larger context of what others have said and providing templates to help them make those moves/5(K).
Find great deals on eBay for they say i say third edition. Shop with confidence. Skip to main content. eBay: "They Say / I Say": The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing (Third Edition) The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing 3rd Edition PDF.
$ or Best Offer. Free Shipping. Search and browse our historical collection to find news, notices of births, marriages and deaths, sports, comics, and much more. 🔥Citing and more! Add citations directly into your paper, Check for unintentional plagiarism and check for writing mistakes.
Prices for They Say Say by Graff 3rd Edition. BUY: RENT The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing with Readings 3rd.
Edition: 3rd Published Rental, Ebook. They Say / I Say: The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing 3rd. Edition: 3rd Published: Format: Paperback.
Author: Gerald Graff; Cathy Birkenstein. ISBN: